Lesliebeth Rosario
FIQWS 10015 & 10115
Professors Kratka & Matyakobova
February 20, 2017
Summary & Response
A Seemingless Connection
There are
many characteristics that make a person unique.
It can either be their hair, looks, or nationality. In the case of “The Shawl’ by Cynthia Ozick
many characters are discriminated because they are Jewish and the story is
being taken place during the Holocaust.
6 million Jews were killed in concentration camps by Nazis under the
control of Adolf Hitler. It’s about
three main characters, Rosa a mother, Magda “the baby, the pet, the little
sister” of Rosa, and Stella her wildcat niece.
Due to the situation going on around them kids were separated from their
loved ones but Rosa fears that her only daughter Magda will get killed if she
disobeys and gets out of the line walking them to the concentration camps or if
she makes contact with anyone else in order to save her. What she does is she keeps her hidden under a
shall the whole time. At one point
Stella was cold so she took the shawl from Rosa exposing Magda, which resulted
in a guard discovering her and throwing her against an electric fence instantly
killing her. The author uses symbolism
with the shawl itself and how it resembles the tallit or Jewish prayer shawl
and how to wrap oneself in the shawl is to be surrounded by the holiness and
protection of the commandments.
I feel like
the Holocaust as a whole was one of the most devastating events that has ever
happened for many reasons. One being
that kids shouldn’t have to pay for consequences they can’t control. Being born Jewish isn’t a choice so it’s not
like anyone had an option of not being taken in if they were Jewish. Stella should have just huddled and find a
different way to keep herself warm and not have to reach over at Rosa and take
her belonging, that was an invasion of space.
Especially if she was hiding a precious life that could have been saved
a little longer if it wasn’t for Stella’s unthinkable actions. I agree with Rosa in hiding her in the first
place because she was closely attached to her in a deep way. It was almost as if Magda was Rosa's sedative
for the moment and being with her helped Rosa get her mind of the devastation
that is surrounding her.
“Rosa” also by Cynthia Ozick is the
follow up of Rosa, whom was introduced in “The Shawl”, thirty years later
living a “meager, isolated existence” in a hotel for the elderly which is
financed by her niece, Stella. This
short story starts off with Rosa in a laundromat and is approached by a elder
flirtatious man who comes from the same place, Warsaw, Poland. She is quick to tell him her Warsaw is not
his Warsaw for the simple fact that they didn’t quite go through the same
things. Still devastated by the death of
her daughter, Rosa writes letters to her to keep her spirit alive in order to
feel sane and better about herself.
Irony appears in “Rosa” in a few different parts some humorous and some
tragic. For example, Rosa survived the
Holocaust only to be confined in Miami with some of the same people she had so
much contempt in her earlier life.
I believe that any mother who was so
close to their only kid to then have it all taken away in the matter of seconds
is never going to view life in the same way.
I personally love the fact that she kept her daughter, Magda, alive with
writing her letters as years go by because it’s almost as if Rosa experienced
everything Magda “accomplished” so far in her life. I don’t know if I could live knowing I
witnessed my own kids death, but the fact that she kept her life ongoing shows
that overall Rosa is a strong independent woman and she can get through any
obstacle.
Being Jewish at the time wasn’t easy at
all. It came with discrimination,
alienation, and complete hatred for everyone who happened to be apart of
race. Rosa showed she was a strong woman
both during and after the Holocaust by never breaking character and keeping
herself motivated by keeping Magda’s spirit alive at all times. Something that stood out to me would have to
be when Persky, the flirtatious elderly from the laundromat, said, "I work
from a different theory. For everything there's a bad way of describing, also a
good way. You pick the good way, you get along better." To my interpretation this means that no
matter what happens in life, there’s always a good and a bad. It is just up to you to decide how you want
to view it and how you’re gonna process the situations, to then give off what
would be the tone in your mood and makes you either a happy person or miserable
in general.
Works Cited:
"The Shawl." Short Stories for Students. Ed. Kathleen
Wilson. Vol. 3. Detroit: Gale, 1998. 285-303. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 28 Feb. 2017.
"Rosa." Short Stories for Students. Ed. Ira Mark
Milne. Vol. 22. Detroit: Gale, 2006. 216-241. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 28 Feb. 2017.
No comments:
Post a Comment